Add RedlineBench evaluation result (redline_overall: 49.3)

#176
by sramjee - opened

Adds .eval_results/redlinebench.yaml with Kimi K3's result on RedlineBench
(crosbylegal/RedlineBench),
a Hugging Face registered benchmark for multi-turn contract redlining.

Result: redline_overall = 49.3 (0–100 scale; higher is better)

  • Benchmark: 140 Harbor tasks — 3 grounded SaaS /
    professional-services MSA negotiations (3 scenarios x 4 alternating turns). The agent
    edits a real Word .docx, producing native tracked changes (<w:ins>/<w:del>) and
    threaded margin comments.
  • Metric definition: turn-weighted weighted pass rate. Per task, reward is
    clamp((earned - penalty) / total_positive) over weighted attorney-authored rubric
    verdicts; rewards are averaged within input groups, then the 12 (scenario x turn)
    cells are weighted equally so later turns don't dominate.
  • Judging: 3-LLM judge panel (gpt-5.4-mini + claude-haiku-4-5 +
    gemini-3.1-flash-lite), strict majority vote per rubric criterion. The panel is
    deliberately outside the family of the model under test.
  • Harness: agent=kimi-k3, via the public reproduction driver at
    https://github.com/crosbylegal/redline-bench
  • Report / methodology: https://intelligence.crosby.ai/benchmark/

Note on the filename: redlinebench.yaml refers to crosbylegal/RedlineBench
(contract negotiation), which is the dataset.id in the YAML. There are unrelated
Hub datasets with similar names (e.g. feichtb/redlinebench, on construction
drawings) — this result is not from those.

This is a post-publication run; the originally published report covers GPT-5.5,
Claude Fable 5, Gemini 3.5 Flash, and Claude Opus 4.8. Same harness, same judge
panel, same metric.

Ready to merge
This branch is ready to get merged automatically.

Sign up or log in to comment